Paid to Decide
I had a problem that was bothering me. I decided to go see Bob, my boss, for help.
In his office, I explained my predicament.
To my great surprise, he said, "Get out of my office!"
He was stern. Not necessarily upset, but obviously not happy.
I couldn't believe what I was hearing. I needed a moment to process it, so I said, "What?"
Then he said something that really surprised me.
"Get out of my office or I will fire you."
He wasn't joking. And I was shocked because this didn't at all sound like Bob.
I got up from my chair and began to leave. As I reached the doorway, I found the courage to turn and ask, "What just happened?"
He said, "You don't have a problem. You have a decision. It's a decision you don't want to make. You want me to make it for you. You want to be able to go to the other people involved in this situation and tell them, 'Bob says,' so you can let yourself off the hook."
"So you can leave here and go make the decision. Or you can stay and get fired, and I'll make the decision for you."
"This is your decision to make. I'm paying you to make decisions. If I have to make them for you, then I don't need you."
I had never thought about being paid to make decisions. I always thought of myself as a problem solver. That's what I thought I did all day long. People would come to me with a problem, and we would put our heads together and come up with a solution.
What I hadn't understood was that solving problems and making decisions aren't necessarily the same thing. Sometimes people don't need help finding a solution. They need someone willing to take responsibility for choosing one. And I was always willing to take the risk of being the one responsible.
That conversation (I guess it wasn't really a conversation; he talked and I listened) changed the way I viewed my job. It set my mind in an entirely new direction, one that stayed with me for the rest of my working life.
Bob continued to reinforce that lesson. He coached his team and taught us things by saying...
Not making a decision is making a decision. You have to decide not to make a decision.
I can forgive mistakes when you are trying your best. I can't forgive mistakes because you did nothing and allowed circumstances to take control.
We make decisions and then evaluate them. We don't continue down a path simply because we made a decision. If it turns out to be wrong, we make an adjustment. We don't throw good money after bad.
Don't bring me problems. Bring me solutions. If you present me with a problem, you had better also present some possible solutions.
You are paid to make decisions.
Bob never used the old axiom, "It's better to ask for forgiveness than permission." Largely because we knew what our jobs were and didn't need to ask for either. If you find yourself unable to make a decision because you don't know the extent of your authority, then you need to ask for a better job description.
I became a good decision maker.
Making difficult decisions
I learned something else along the way. Decisions that appear difficult aren't always difficult once you understand what you are really deciding.
When I was given a business to run. I knew that my assignment probably wouldn't be a long one, because I was moved every few years to run a different business.
One of the things I was asked to decide was what to do with a plant that manufactured a product that was dangerous to make.
Almost everyone I talked to mentioned the dangers of this particular product within the first few sentences of our conversation when we talked about this business. The owners and my higher-level managers wanted me to decide what to do with the plant.
So I went to the plant. I looked around. I talked to everyone. And I decided to close it. Close the plant and send everyone home.
Was that a hard decision? No, it wasn't.
It was easier to tell someone they were going to lose their job than to have to tell their loved ones that he or she wasn't coming home because we had decided to keep a dangerous facility open and they were killed in an explosion at work.
When we go to work, we need to be able to come home. Whole. All our fingers, all our toes.
Sometimes we spend so much time worrying about making a decision that we lose sight of what we are actually deciding. We weigh the cost, the inconvenience, the reaction of others, and the consequences to ourselves.
But occasionally, when you strip all that away, the decision becomes pretty simple.
The difficult part isn't always making the decision. Sometimes it's having the courage to accept what the decision means and take responsibility for it.
A business is more than its numbers
I was put in charge of several businesses that needed turning around.
The first thing you have to do is get your team in place. Everyone needs to know what they are supposed to be doing and have the authority to do it. There are decisions to be made when forming a team. You need to build a business TEAM that will last long after you hand the reins to a different person.
So you have to look for your replacement pretty quickly into the process. I would do that and be ready when the time came to offer up a name. Sometimes I was asked. Other times I was told who would take over for me.
I thought that was part of the job. Your responsibility isn't just to run a business. It's to build an organization that can continue running without you.
In one of my finance classes, the professor said something along these lines:
"We are going to study numbers. These numbers are generated by a business. They are generated by the activities of the business. It is NOT the other way around. The numbers do not generate the business."
If you are in business very long, you will run into people who are "numbers people." They are good people, and we need them. But some (not all) think the numbers are the be-all and end-all of business.
Numbers are important. But they are a reflection of what is happening in a business. The decisions made by managers and the execution of processes by the people doing the work create those numbers.
You can't manage a business by looking only at the numbers. You have to understand the people, the decisions, and the activities that produce them. The numbers are your measurement of how things turned out. The numbers are a result of activity... they come "after the fact".
Go forth and make decisions
Looking back, I think Bob taught me something much bigger than how to manage a business.
He taught me that responsibility comes with authority, and authority comes with responsibility... but neither means much without the willingness to act.
You won't always make the right decision. That's okay. Make the best decision you can with the information you have. Take responsibility for it. Evaluate the results. And be willing to change direction when necessary.
But don't avoid making the decision.
After all, you're being paid to make it.
Go forth and make decisions.
